novel writingWriting Fear Free

Writing Fear Free: Reviews

After working on a book for months or years, finding an agent and publisher or going indie, and then seeing the book to press, you’d think the hard part was over.

Wrong. You still have to face reviews. You want people to like your book; that’s why you put it out there for sale. What if book reviewers and online customers pan it?

That can be a scary prospect.

Really, there aren’t many careers in which people are faced so directly with critiques of their work from so many sources. It’s not like engineers have a web page devoted entirely to one of their designs: “The water line out on highway 21 gets water to my house pretty well, but if the engineer had used a 15-inch diameter pipe instead of a 14-inch diameter, it would have been a better design. And I really thought the installation crew should have worn yellow vests instead of orange. 3.5 stars.” Can you imagine?

Some writers claim never to read reviews; some writers will respond to every single one. I fall somewhere in between. I read them, and unless it is an email thanking people whom I solicited for a review, I do not respond to them. I figure that my part in the review process was writing the book. Once it’s out there, it’s out there, and it’s the reader’s turn to weigh in.

There are two different ways your work will be reviewed. The first is by book bloggers and reviewers whom you solicit or who buy your book and review it for you. These fine folks do this as a hobby, and it is worth it to send them free copies, just as if you were a traditional publisher sending ARC’s (advanced review copies). Book bloggers are to indie authors what the New York Times is to big-name authors. Even traditional houses solicit book bloggers. Their reviews are thorough and very professional, at least the ones who have reviewed Charlotte Collins have been. They include publication information, a summary, and a useful critique. They usually re-post their reviews on Goodreads, Amazon, and BN. I highly recommend all of my reviewers to anyone.

The second method of review is customer reviews. These are the ones that show up on Goodreads, Amazon, BN, and etc. from people who paid money to read what you wrote or who received it in a giveaway. These are reviews from your target audience, and they are just as important as the blog reviews. Because these people paid for you work, it’s good to read what they have to say, especially regarding format and grammar. They may not like your plot or characters or theme, but that’s the same chance everyone takes when they buy a book. But they deserve to have a quality product, even if they don’t like the contents.

Here’s a summary of what I’ve learned so far:

  • Well-written, unbiased reviews can be very helpful, even the ones that contain critiques. Authors should be open to hearing both praise and critique and growing from it.
  • Solicit reviews from book bloggers who enjoy your genre. Good reviews from them can mean lots of good exposure.
  • Expect a certain percentage of negative customer reviews. Not everyone likes the same thing.
  • Also expect some insulting reviews. Every author gets them.
  • Think carefully before responding to any negative review. No matter what you do, as the author, you are going to come off looking defensive and petty.
  • Some customer reviewers may not have finished your book, and their review may contain factual misconceptions as a result.
  • Worse, some people may not have even read your book before reviewing it. Many customers use stores’ rating systems to protest price or even something like cover art, which is usually out of your control.
  • Not every reviewer uses the same star scale. Some will only give 5 stars to the Bible.
  • Not every review is going to be unbiased. Some are going to be predisposed to loving your work (your well-meaning family and friends); some will be predisposed to being critical.

Incidentally, that last bullet point is why I have chosen not to review books here, especially Austen-related tomes. As a writer in this genre, I can’t say that I would be unbiased when coming to another sequel or anthology.

Also, would you even believe me? How do you know I’m not just saying nice things about a friend’s book? Or that I’m not saying negative things about a competitor? It’s a minefield I choose to avoid.

I’d rather just flat-out say, “This is my friend’s book. Would you like to read it?”

So how do you face reviews the fear-free way? I don’t really know. I’m still learning.

5 thoughts on “Writing Fear Free: Reviews

  1. I agree with everything you have said, esp. “Not every reviewer has the same scale.” This is so true. I asked a lady whom I had met on a fan fiction blog to review my first novel. She was English, and I thought the perfect person for an Austen re-imagining. She said that she “loved” my book, but only gave it four stars. When I asked why, that is, how could I improve it, she said that only Austen would have gotten five stars from her. Fair enough.

  2. I’m one of those authors who doesn’t read their reviews. I don’t have a clue how many reviews I have on Amazon and don’t know if there are any independent reviews floating around out there. Reviews, good or bad, paralyze me.

    When I wrote fan fiction and posted on public boards, I learned that a small portion of readers enjoyed taking the story apart and trying to show how smartie-pants they were by speculating. Reviewers have their own version by which they try to speculate why the writer wrote what they did. Many readers enjoy a book/fiction and say so. A small portion were over the moon in love with the story. By far, the vast majority of readers never say a thing. I think that goes for reviews as well.

  3. I think you have a sensible approach, Susan. About 1 percent (or slightly less) of my sales have resulted in reviews. That leaves 99 percent of my readers who will “vote” with their pocketbooks only. This silent majority is really important, and repeat business is crucial.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.